Saturday, November 14, 2026

Review: Anger is Only a Shadow (by Elizabeth Acevedo)

My Rating: 4 stars

My first exposure to Elizabeth Acevedo’s works was her debut novel-in-verse The Poet X, which I read for book club a few years back and despite it being a new-to-me experience (i.e. my first time reading a novel-in-verse), I was absolutely blown away by the beautiful, emotional, heartfelt rendering of Xiomara’s coming-of-age experience.  Since then, I’ve been on the lookout for Acevedo’s works and have put nearly all her backlist on my TBR (though unfortunately, getting to the books have been a challenge due to the overwhelming number of books I already have on my list).  I did read her novel Family Lore when it came out 3 years ago, but it didn’t land as emotionally for me compared to the novel-in-verse format that is her specialty.

In her newest work Anger is Only a Shadow, Acevedo returns to form, bringing us a poignant, emotional tale about a rebellious teenager named Lil whose desire for freedom constantly gets her in trouble.  After her latest antics land her again in juvenile detention, Lil is released on probation, but has to wear an ankle monitor and adhere to a curfew.  The girlfriends that she was with at the time however, did not get her same fate, and the guilt she feels from this, combined with judgment from others, weights her down both mentally and emotionally.  The only person who understands her and loves her without judgment is her brother Aldwin who is off at college, but he has been very distant lately, seemingly hiding from his family and refusing to see them or take their calls.  While awaiting her court date, Lil must navigate her “new reality” of not only having every move she makes monitored (whether officially by her probation officer or by her parents who struggle to keep her out of trouble), but also having to return to a school environment where the judgment and hostilities are especially intense.  What bothers Lil the most however, is not knowing what is going on with her brother, who has been acting strangely for several months, sometimes calling her in the middle of the night and saying things that worry her.  Things ultimately come to a head when Lil finds herself in a position where she must decide between her personal freedom or helping the brother who has loved her unconditionally through her struggles.

One of the things that I love and admire about Acevedo’s works is the way she writes about the realities of teenage life with such clarity, and especially never shies away from the harsher, more difficult topics.  In this instance, she explores the impact our criminal justice system can have on young people (particularly young people of color) and its attempts to hold them accountable for their mistakes.  While holding people accountable is noble and necessary, the execution of the process is oftentimes flawed, which can, in some instances, result in the system doing more harm than good – a concern that Acevedo mentions in her Author’s note that she has seen first-hand in her work as a visiting instructor at a youth center for incarcerated women and teenagers.  Through her realistic portrayals of these teenagers’ experiences as well as the emotional energy of her lyrical, poetic prose, Acevedo brings much-needed awareness to an important and critical issue.

Another issue that Acevedo writes about with clarity and acuity is mental illness -- a decidedly difficult topic to broach on its own. In this instance, she pairs it with young people's encounters with the criminal justice system, creating a poignant portrayal of the many struggles that are part and parcel to the messiness of daily life.

With Acevedo’s previous work, I actually read the words on the page, but after the wonderful experience of hearing her read excerpts of her works at various points, I knew that with this new book, it was a no brainer for me to listen to the audio book version.  Indeed, Acevedo does an excellent job here and I definitely feel that my experience of this story would’ve been very different if I had read it in print instead. In terms of recommendation, it should come as no surprise that I would definitely recommend picking this one up, especially for those who are fans of poetry and novels-in-verse, which, of course, are Acevedo’s fortes.  As I mentioned earlier in my review, I absolutely intend to continue working through her backlist while also keeping an eye out for her new works.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment